Without meaning to be rude, do you think it might be an idea to tag these threads onto one of the others you have started today? Or maybe post in the 'Just Starting Out' section? Seriously, 'cologne' will not get you girls. It's about personality, physical attraction etc, etc if she likes you, she won't care what fragrance you are wearing. Wear it for yourself first; if you feel good about it (and you) the confidence radiating from you will gain you more positive attention than any fragrance ever could.
On topic: Either will work for High School.